Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kevin Alexander's avatar

Fantastic picks, Keith! I think you could build an entire -400 level songwriting course around Pleased to Meet me, specifically "Valentine" and "Can't Hardly Wait." Both are about as close to pop perfection as one can get.

And great point about PJ's Ten representing a generational shift. From this observer's perch, what really set them apart was their ambition. While other bands were actively shunning the spotlight (sometimes to their detriment of their careers), Pearl Jam seemed okay with it? Never in any kind of oily way- they just knew what they wanted and went after it.

Of the "Big 4" Seattle bands (PJ, Nirvana, Soundgarden, and Alice in Chains), Ten is also the one that sounds the closest to what we all knew at the time as "rock." it's short on sludge or feedback and long on pop sensibilities.

P.S. Can I just say how jealous I am that you (Andy) got to hear Pleased to Meet me for the first time?

Expand full comment
Brad Kyle's avatar

Jolly good show, Andy! Keith, I dig your choices, but, like Andy, I'm really not all that familiar with them. I heard much of "Tim" upon release, and tried to get into The Replacements, but, they didn't quite click with me! I'm well aware, though of Paul Westerberg's talent, but I think they were pitched to me as sort of an alt version of power pop, or perhaps its next logical step.

Andy, I really appreciate how a guest (Keith, of course, here) can bring in some records you're not familiar with, and you take the time to listen to them, and pick out a favorite song or two so you can bounce relevant questions about the music to your guest, and share a common ground with which songs caught your ear! I think folks ought to zero in on that, and give you mad props for the thorough prep you do! Well done, mate!

Expand full comment
22 more comments...

No posts